Bokator World
bokatorworld
Monks
Home
5

Contact

  • Monks
  • Tholun23@gmail.com
  • +855015897766

Loading...

Loading...

The middle cabinet of displayed bronzes at the National Museum in Phnom Penh, recently installed to celebrate the 75th anniversary of diplomatic relations between the USA and Cambodia, holds 2 exhibits that were part of a group of fourteen pieces that were returned by the Metropolitan Museum of New York in July 2024. The Met realized that the provenance for the 14 items was very dodgy, in non-technical terms, and decided to do the right thing. The larger of the two is a magnificent image of a seated Lokeshvara in the elegant Baphuon style of the eleventh century, depicted in the king-like royal ease posture and considered by experts as one of the finest and most important surviving large-scale bronze sculptures from the Angkor period. It found its way to The Met in 1992, sold to the museum by none other than Douglas Latchford, a name synonymous with the systematic looting of Khmer-era temples across Cambodia and Thailand for more than fifty years. It was the looter-turned-informer, Toek Tik, who said he unearthed the bronze statue using a metal detector around 1990. He stowed the bronze in a backpack and took it to Siem Reap where he sold it to a trafficker, known to Cambodian authorities as Sleeping Giant, who worked for Latchford. Photographs on Latchford’s own computer show the dirt-encrusted statue undergoing restoration in a workshop prior to its sale to The Met. It was featured by Latchford and Emma Bunker in their 2011 scholarly book, Khmer Bronzes. The sculpture’s coiffure is formed by elegantly arranged loops of braided hair with a tiny Amitabha Buddha seated in the front, confirming the image as representing the Bodhisattva Avalokiteshvara (better known in Cambodia as Lokeshvara). The deity wears a simple plain sampot with an over-fold and is adorned with a discreet set of jewelry including armlets, bracelets and a necklace with a rumduol flower pendant. The only visible damage is a missing right hand and a broken ear lobe. Broad incisions marking the eyebrows, moustache, chin and a third eye would’ve been inset with silver and obsidian, while his eyes were inlaid with crystals, giving the image a sense of inner life. The relaxed secular pose and distinctive individual appearance suggest that the image represents the spiritual identity of a member of the elite class in the guise of Lokeshvara, reflecting a custom associated with indigenous Khmer cults of ancestor worship. This custom culminated in the images of Jayavarman VII’s deceased first queen, reflected in statues of Prajnaparamita, in both bronze and stone, in the latter part of the twelfth-century. The years-long project by EFEO and Apsara Authority in uncovering the presence of a bronze-making foundry in the Royal Palace area of Angkor Thom has breathed life into the possibility that such elegant bronzes were made inside the royal city itself. A suggestion that the image may’ve originated from Prasat Beng in Phnom Srok district in Banteay Meanchey province is yet to be verified. The Met made the unexpected announcement to deaccession the 14 Khmer images in December 2023, marking a major U-turn on their previous policy of ignoring Cambodia’s claims for repatriation, and instead cooperated with the U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York and Homeland Security Investigations in sending back antiquities specifically linked to Douglas Latchford. The second smaller bronze is this remarkable face of Shiva, with a faintly menacing thousand-yard stare, a bronze mask that once adorned a life-size sculpture of the Hindu god inside a sacred temple, but suffered the fate of too many beautiful bronze statues that were either stolen, broken into pieces or melted down. This fragment adds weight to the Khmers’ ability to produce large-scale bronze sculptures in Angkor from the tenth century. We have seen a series of incredible bronze statues from the next century, during the Baphuon-era, and a similar face and head from that period is in the National Museum of Cambodia’s collection. For the Met’s Shiva face, the eyebrows are formed by a single ridged line and a narrow moustache with curvy tips is depicted above lightly rimmed lips. The eyeballs (and third eye) are marked by empty sockets that were probably inlaid with obsidian and silver used for the whites of the eyes. The damage to the hair and crown leaves us guessing at its style. The only public provenance issued by The Met is that the bronze face was donated to the museum by Douglas Latchford in 1998, to mark the thirty-plus year tenure of Martin Lerner, as their South & Southeast Asian art curator. Where Latchford obtained the bronze is a missing piece in the jigsaw.Credit By :Andy Brouwer
0 comment
0 comment

Let’s return to the unmarked bronzes recently installed in display cabinets at the National Museum for the 75th anniversary celebrations to mark diplomatic relations between the USA and Cambodia. In the right-hand cabinet are three bronzes, but for this post I’ll concentrate on just one of them, the Buddhist Triad, at the rear of the display. All of the bronzes were returned to Cambodia from the United States, either being rescued from private collectors or from the Metropolitan Museum in New York. This triad was handed-over to American authorities by wealthy collector James H Clark. It had been featured in a glossy coffee-table book, published by co-authors Douglas Latchford and Emma Bunker in 2011, titled Khmer Bronzes: New Interpretations of the Past. The text from the book is as follows: ‘A Buddhist triad comprising a Naga-enthroned Buddha flanked by Lokeshvara and Prajnaparamita figures set on a single base became a national cult image during the first decades of Jayavarman VII’s reign, continuing a sacred concept that had already been represented by the Khmer during the last half of the tenth century. In such triads, the Buddha represents Absolute Truth, Lokeshvara compassion, and Prajnaparamita the personification of wisdom. The deities are identified by their respective attributes and wear royal dress appropriate to their importance in the current Buddhist hierarchy. A delightful touch is provided by the Naga’s tail running up the side of the coils in back. The ushnisha-cover surmounting the Naga’s primary head highlights the Naga’s elevation in status. These Buddhist triads follow a basic iconography in which the deities are royally garbed to reflect Buddhism’s status as the state religion with close ties to the ruler and the court. They reflect the crux of Jayavarman’s early religious vision, that the compassion of Lokeshvara and perfect wisdom of Prajnaparamita together engender Buddhahood. The triads are all generally assembled from five separately cast elements comprising the base, the Naga’s hood, and the three deities, each attached by a pendant tang that slots into the base designed with an expanded middle section to lead the worshipper’s eye directly to the Buddha.’ [Extract from Khmer Bronzes, 2011]. The Buddhist Triad was repatriated to Cambodia early in 2023, though it’s only now on display for the first time. It was in August 2022 that the American authorities handed over to Cambodian representatives in New York, twenty-five (25) precious pieces of Khmer art, both in stone and bronze, that were previously in the private collection of American tech billionaire James H Clark. A former professor at Stanford, Clark co-founded the Netscape Communications Corporation in 1994, but had been duped by rogue dealer Douglas Latchford between the years 2003 and 2008 into purchasing a selection of Khmer artifacts to decorate his Miami Beach, Florida penthouse in the United States. He paid around USD35 million for the Khmer artifacts, though after he sold the penthouse, the collection had been kept in storage out of sight for the past decade, before the US federal authorities contacted him. They presented evidence that Latchford provided false statements, fake provenance documents and illegal customs paperwork to hide the real identity of the looted sculptures, and Clark voluntarily handed over the works of art, that also included the enormous Ganesha which you can see on display in the museum’s courtyard. The American authorities announced the surrender of the items at the start of 2022 and they were formally given to Cambodia’s Ambassador in New York that same year. Latchford was indicted by the Southern District of New York in 2019 on charges of antiquities trafficking, but never stood trial for his more than fifty years of illegal activities from his Bangkok headquarters, and died a year later. A separate post will highlight the Lokeshvara and Vishnu which are displayed in the same cabinet.Credit By :Andy Brouwer
0 comment
0 comment

The final two bronzes of those recently installed in three display cabinets at the National Museum for the 75th anniversary celebrations to mark diplomatic relations between the USA and Cambodia, came from private collections in the United States, and which have been repatriated back to Cambodia in recent times. On the front-left side of the cabinet is a beautifully cast bronze statue of Vishnu, which was returned in late July 2024 from the Lindemann family collection, the only bronze in a haul of 33 Khmer antiquities. The extensive collection of billionaire couple George and Frayda Lindemann, kept at their Palm Beach, Florida mansion, first came to light when pictures of their home were published in the Architectural Digest magazine in 2008, and re-posted in 2017. They were sold to Lindemann by Douglas Latchford, who ran an international trafficking network from his headquarters in Bangkok for more than fifty years. They were purchased over several decades by Lindemann senior, who’s believed to have paid at least USD20+ million for them. In fact, Latchford included three of the Lindemann’s finest bronze pieces in his 2011 book, Khmer Bronzes, though only the four-armed bronze of the Hindu god Vishnu has found its way back home, posing the obvious question as to the current whereabouts of the other bronzes. One clue to their provenance may lie in the 1997 brochure published by Spink and Son, for an exhibition sale titled A Divine Art: Sculpture of South East Asia, at their upmarket art dealership in swanky St James’s, London. The bronze Vishnu was included in the sale with the Spinks and Latchford partnership inexorably linked to shady practices over decades. In addition, the Lindemann’s were close acquaintances of Latchford and his associate Martin Lerner, and they donated some art pieces to the Metropolitan Museum in New York, where Lerner was the curator. The description of the bronze Vishnu in the Latchford & Emma Bunker authored book, Khmer Bronzes, is as follows: ‘Several significant large bronzes remain from the Pre Rup period (under King Rajendravarman II in the middle of the tenth-century), displaying a mixture of archaistic Bakheng and Koh Ker styles. Most Pre Rup-style bronzes are less hieratic than earlier tenth-century bronzes and technically superb. A late Pre Rup-style bronze Vishnu image on an integrally cast base is portrayed with the left leg placed slightly ahead of the right leg, lending the figure a relaxed naturalistic appearance. The deity, identified by his attributes, the chakra, conch, mace, and lotus bud, wears a tiered square headdress with one corner aligned with the face plane, an earlier version of the headdress that distinguishes the slightly later tenth-century Lakshmi in the James Clark Collection (a separate bronze sold by Latchford to Clark). A royal diadem is attached at the back by ribbons tied in a square knot, imitating a real gold example. Vishnu is clothed in a sampot chang kben with an overlap at the waist and a draped pocket on the left hip accompanied by a scarf with fishtail terminates arranged so that the outer one is shorter than the inner one that it overlaps – the opposite of the earlier Bakheng-style fishtail panel-arrangement in which the outer, overlapping fishtail panel is longer.’ [Extract from Khmer Bronzes, 2011]. The second bronze, front-right side of the cabinet with the Buddhist Triad in the background, is a bronze of Lokeshvara in excellent condition. It was in August 2022 that the American authorities handed over to Cambodian representatives in New York, twenty-five (25) precious pieces of Khmer art, both in stone and bronze, that were previously in the private collection of American tech billionaire James H Clark. Most of them arrived in Cambodia at the start of 2023, and the remainder, including this Lokeshvara, reached the National Museum in July 2024. Clark obtained his Khmer collection from rogue dealer Douglas Latchford between the years 2003 and 2008, spending around USD35 million to acquire the antiquities. Once US federal authorities provided evidence that they were looted, Clark voluntarily handed over the works of art, for repatriation to Cambodia. Lokeshvara was the common title in Cambodia for the much-loved Bodhisattva (or buddha-to-be) of infinite compassion and mercy by the name of Avalokiteshvara, which translates as the Lord who looks in every direction. Large free-standing sandstone sculptures of this supreme deity were positioned in prominent population areas far and wide across the kingdom, whether the sculptures were the spectacular examples of the Radiating Lokeshvara, or the equally substantial (non-Radiating) Lokeshvara. Smaller bronze variations were also popular as they were more portable and were often part of a triad including Prajnaparamita and Buddha sheltering under Naga (Muchalinda). Easily identifiable by the seated Amitabha Buddha at the front of his chignon, Lokeshvara became much more prominent under the reign of King Jayavarman VII at the end of the twelfth century, who the king associated with his late father. This copper-alloy example has four arms, some had two, others eight, and he holds four specific attributes; the right lower hold a lotus and the right upper, a rosary; the left upper holds a scripture, and the left lower hand cradles a water vase. The body is adorned with a pectoral necklace of lotus flowers and upper arm bands, bracelets, pendant earrings and anklets. Under the chignon headdress, the face has large lips, almond-shaped eyes and a third eye in the forehead. The short sampot sits high on the waist, with a belt with hanging pendants and has a tapering fishtail central fold, both front and back. The style fits neatly into the Bayon art style characteristic of the king’s reign .Credit By :Andy Brouwer
0 comment
0 comment

The public display of bronzes at the National Museum in Phnom Penh is undergoing changes as the museum team prepare to send 125 of their precious bronzes to the Guimet Museum in Paris for the much-anticipated exhibition, Royal Bronzes of Angkor, an Art of the Divine, which will open its doors in the French capital on 30 April and continue until 8 September 2025. It will be the largest exhibition of Khmer bronze art ever, so if you get the opportunity, you must visit. That means there are some gaps in the Returned Sculptures section of the museum reserved for recently repatriated objects. On my visit yesterday some of the best bronzes had been removed and a small picture of the item left in its place. I imagine other bronzes from the museum’s vast reserve storage will take their place in the display cases but it does mean we have a good idea of some of the returned bronzes that will be heading to Paris. These 10 bronzes were on display until recently in the Returned Sculptures section, so expect them to be on the flight to Paris sometime soon.Credit By :Andy Brouwer
0 comment
0 comment

Additional bronze statues have been added to the display in the Returned Sculptures section of the National Museum and all 8 artifacts highlighted in this post, were returned to Cambodia in June 2022 after being handed over to the Cambodian Ambassador in June 2021 by the New York District Attorney’s Office and Homeland Security Investigations. The United States authorities had seized a haul of 27 Khmer antiquities, 24 of which were recovered from Subhash Kapoor, one of the world's biggest antiques smugglers, through his Manhattan Gallery, while the other three were seized from the Nancy Wiener Gallery, also in New York. Their value was believed to be around US$3.8 million. The collaboration between the Cambodian government and American officials has seen a large number of Khmer treasures returned home in recent years and this is set to continue. Kapoor sold looted artworks from Cambodia, Afghanistan, India, Pakistan, Nepal, and Thailand using fake export/import and provenance papers, and was a contemporary of disgraced dealer Douglas Latchford. However, Kapoor is facing justice for his crimes, which Latchford managed to evade, and has spent the last ten years in jail in India and is now facing extradition to the United States. The question of how Kapoor amassed his collection of Khmer artworks remains unanswered for now. Most of the pieces are representations of Buddha from the Angkor period with a couple of exceptions, including a seated image of Vajrasattva, who was one of the principal deities of Vajrayana (‘the way of the thunderbolt’), which enabled adherents to aim for enlightenment through tantric rituals and mantras. The vajra (thunderbolt) and ghanta (bell) were the iconic attributes which he is holding in his hands; this type of Buddhism was very popular amongst the elites in the 12-13th centuries. The unique bronze conch and stand, with Hevajra and dancing acolyte features was repatriated in 2022 from the USA too.Credit By :Andy Brouwer
0 comment
0 comment

Khmer Art Overseas: A collection of Khmer art in an art gallery in France recently came to my attention. Owned by Beryl Cavallini, the Galerie Golconda is housed in St Paul de Vence, in a medieval listed house on the Cote d’Azur. They pride themselves on museum-quality art pieces from private collections around the world, with over 1,500 pieces of art in their collection. The owner has a particular interest in Khmer art and a dozen antiquities are presented here from their online catalogue. The gallery prides itself on the legal provenance of their works of art.Credit By :Andy Brouwer
0 comment
0 comment